Showing posts with label Globalisation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Globalisation. Show all posts

Sugar Daddies

Sugarcane has fuelled the corruption of political power in some states of India – the world’s largest sugar producer. But, as Dionne Bunsha reveals, it’s the small farmers who pay the price.

Meet Balasaheb Shinde. He’s wondering how he will abandon his children. Balasaheb is
a small farmer of sugarcane in Beed, Maharashtra. He’s so deep in debt that this year he and his wife will have to migrate to find work as cane cutters. His youngest son will drop out of school and go with them. But his three older children can’t stop their education. He will have to leave them alone in the village.

‘There’s no-one to look after them. For the first time, I am leaving to work as a labourer, even though I have my own farm. It’s not profitable to grow sugarcane any longer,’ says Balasaheb. ‘The loans keep piling up. The moneylenders are demanding repayments. How will I manage?’

Meet Gopinath Munde. His party controls the Ambejogai sugar co-operative where Balasaheb is a member. The factory hasn’t paid outstanding dues to farmers or its workers. Munde is leader of the opposition in Maharashtra, India’s largest sugar-producing state. In the previous government he was Deputy Chief Minister. The factory is situated in his constituency. Its chairperson is an associate from his political party, the right-wing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Munde recently set up several sugar factories nearby. His wife is the chairperson of one. He is chairperson of another. Politicians control most sugar-processing units in this state, and almost all of them are co-operatives.

Termed ‘the lazy man’s crop’ (because it is so easy to make money from), sugarcane farming was introduced in western Maharashtra by the pioneers of the co-operative movement during the 1950s. They were politicians who pumped huge amounts of government funds into co-operatives, developing roads and cornering a large chunk of the subsidies for irrigation. The region developed far ahead of the rest of the state.

A child joins family members cutting cane.
Photo: Dionne Bunsha

Politicians like Munde now control not only sugar factories, but also other co-operatives within their constituencies – banks, dairies, irrigation and education institutions. Right from the sarpanch (local representative) at the village level to the Chief Minister, the entire political network is closely linked with sugar co-operatives.

Every link in the chain gets a piece of the pie. Sugar barons appoint their cronies or family members as chairpersons and directors. Often they manipulate government policy in their favour. The ‘loyal supporters’ lower down the line are awarded contracts and employment – patronage politics at its most efficient. For the members of the sugar co-operatives themselves barely a few scraps remain.

In the Ambejogai co-operative they suspect that Munde would like their factory shut down. It would mean more business for the co-operatives nearby which he runs. Munde controls the economy and politics of his constituency. He prospers while the members of the Ambejogai co-operative are on the verge of starvation.

To gain control over a co-operative means to establish a fiefdom, to capture a ‘vote bank’. Politicians from the ruling centrist alliance government control 99 per cent of Maharashtra’s sugar industry. The rival BJP is still trying to break into the syndicate.

Corruption
Today, the industry is in trouble – 56 of Maharashtra’s 163 sugar mills are bankrupt, ruined by corruption and nepotism. Second and third generation politicians have squeezed out all profits, leaving the state government to bail them out. The state government contributed a 30-per-cent redeemable stake in the equity of these co-operatives, but few have repaid the equity. It also stood guarantee for the 60-percent equity taken as loans, some of which haven’t been repaid either.

Last season 19 factories took loans to crush cane. They started production for a short while and then stopped. The aim never was to operate them – merely to take the money and run. They didn’t repay the bank or the few farmers whose cane was crushed.
Are the mills really broke, or have they been made so? ‘The management wants to show losses. Or else how will they make money?’ asks Ramgonda Patil, a small farmer in Kolhapur district. ‘They inflate expenses and siphon off funds. Then they keep borrowing from the banks to pay farmers. The money never reaches us. But we have to bear the burden of those loans. If run properly, the business is profitable.’

Farmers get a very small part of the revenue. Sugar sells at Rs12 ($0.26) per kilo on the domestic market and Rs10 ($0.21) internationally. But farmers get only Rs6.25 ($0.14) or less.

‘The co-operatives are run by those who have no stake in it at all. It should not be the side-business of politicians,’ says Madhav Godbole, a former bureaucrat who has suggested stopping government involvement in this sector.

But who’s listening? So far, a bankrupt state government has shelled out Rs65 million ($1.41 million) to pay off the co-operatives’ bad debts. There’s another Rs4,000 million ($86.96 million) in guarantees yet to be paid.
The long wait for bullock carts delivering to the Ambejogai sugar
mill
Photo: Dionne Bunsha

Farmers have also felt the blow. ‘The co-operative is ours. But we have no say in the way it is run,’ says Ramgonda Patil. ‘Yes, we have elected the directors. But what choice do we have? They use money and muscle power during the elections.’ Any attempts to challenge their authority are nipped in the bud. ‘If anyone dares to ask a question at the cooperative meetings, he is taken out by their thugs. The directors of the factory run their own goonda raj (gangster rule) here.’

Cane growers are being squeezed from both ends. Sugarcane prices offered by factories have fallen by around 25 per cent in the past five years. Around a third of factories haven’t even paid farmers the Indian Government’s minimum price of Rs695 ($15.1) per tonne. In the season that started in October, industry experts estimate that only five per cent of the factories will be able to pay farmers the minimum price. And even this minimum price is not sufficient to meet farmers’ expenses.

Production costs have risen by around two-thirds in the last five years. There have been huge hikes in power, irrigation and other charges due to economic liberalization. ‘Every year our debts rise by another Rs10-15,000 ($217- 326). Cane prices are not enough to recover our costs. Many factories don’t pay in time. So interest on our bank loans also keeps piling up,’ says Ramgonda. At the end of the 18-month crop, a farmer’s net income is approximately Rs5,000 ($109) per acre – that’s just Rs278 ($6) a month.

Drowning in debt, many small farmers have had to sell part of their land. The moneylenders are raking it in. They charge farmers interest at rates anywhere between 35 and 60 per cent. If the farmer can’t pay, they just take over the land. Earlier, when government and co-operative banks came here, moneylenders lost their hold over small peasants. Now they are back with a vengeance.

Why not shift to another crop? Many have switched to soya beans. But prices of soya too have crashed by a half in the last year. ‘What else can we grow? We have to grow cash crops to get money to pay things like medical bills, school fees. It’s also easier to get a bank loan if you grow sugarcane. Until now it was considered a stable crop,’ says Ramgonda. But this season a huge pest attack has destroyed half the crop. Farmers’ incomes are even more fragile.

Neglect

Peasants in other parts of Maharashtra still protest about being the neglected stepchildren. Their complaints are not unjustified. For example, although sugarcane is grown on only four per cent of Maharashtra’s total cropped area, 60 per cent of irrigated water goes to this crop alone. Bank credit, dairies and other facilities are far more accessible here than in the rest of rural Maharashtra.

It’s from these neglected areas in central Maharashtra that workers migrate to the lush sugarcane belt during the six month harvesting season. Contractors hired by the factory bring them in groups. Some factories haven’t paid contractors’ bills, so these migrants haven’t got their full wages either. Their exploitation is double-edged – both by the factories and by the contractors.
migrant labourers camp out in the plantations
Photo: Dionne Bunsha

Many, like Shivaji, barely get a few hours’ sleep during the cutting season. Yet, after labouring round the clock, Shivaji may not be able to work off the advance he took from the contractor. Before leaving their village in Beed, around 200 kilometres away from the factory, the contractor gave his family Rs20,000 ($435). This is offset against the amount of sugarcane they cut. Like most migrants, Shivaji may return to his village with a debt to repay. ‘If, at the end of the season, we haven’t cut enough cane to offset the advance given to us, we have to pay back the rest. The interest rate is 60 per cent per year,’ he says.

Trapped in a cycle of loans, workers keep coming back to the sugar factories every year. The need for a lump-sum advance for consumption, to marry their children or pay medical bills, makes workers approach the contractor. Families repay the advances by cutting between one to two tonnes of cane per day, at the rate of Rs100-115 ($2.5) per tonne for bullock-cart owners and Rs65 ($1.41) for tractor workers. Often workers are given less, as their unpaid loans are offset against this advance.

In fact Uttam Siserao, a landless labourer from Parbhani, worked for free in the 2001-02 season. He explained: ‘My wife was ill last year and could not work. We had taken Rs10,000 ($217) from the contractor. I worked off Rs5,000 ($107) and the other half was due. After that, she passed away. This year I am repaying her advance.’
Most workers use up their advances in the village itself and buy their daily rations by selling the sugarcane leaves as fodder. They leave with nothing and return home still empty-handed.

Ironically, while millions of sugarcane farmers and workers are starving, the warehouses are overflowing with sugar. Overproduction has resulted in swelling stocks. Factories are desperate to sell them off. To offload stocks, the Government has offered an export subsidy – paying producers to get rid of their sugar. But no-one seems bothered whether the farmers or workers will get a share of the profits.

Shetgonda Patil, a farmer from Kolhapur district, puts it eloquently: ‘We have shares in the factory. We grow the cane. But we don’t get to taste any sugar – not even a pinch.’

New Internationalist December 2003 Available here

Dandi in the time of globalisation

Gandhiji's march to Dandi was the beginning of the end for the British. The 75th anniversary march was a bizarre political pilgrimage with a motley mix of foreigners, Pakistanis, old Gandhians and Congress politicians

DIONNE BUNSHA
In Dandi, Gujarat.
Photographs: Ashima Narain


Meet the self-appointed masseur of the Dandi Yatra 2005, Rajkumar Jeswani. Every night, he massages the feet of his fellow marchers, shares a joke, eases their pain. “I am a poor man, but I wanted to do something for Bapu. This is my Shraddhanjali (offering) for him,” says Rajkumar, a spare parts salesman from Ahmedabad.

Rajkumar read about the march in a local newspaper and decided that he had to make the journey. He didn’t have the money for his train ticket back from Dandi to Ahmedabad, but he had the will to participate, come what may. “I had to find a way to get here. I worked very hard, travelled through many villages to sell more and when I got enough money for the ticket and to look after my family while I was away, I joined Bapuji’s march,” he says. “In this yatra, I have realised what is truth. The kind of love I have got from people on the march and in the villages along the way makes me feel that I was just drifting until now. It’s going to be very sad when we all have to go our separate ways.”

I approached the Dandi Yatra a bit sceptical, smiling at the irony of re-tracing the steps of the Mahatma’s Salt Satyagraha geared with my Nike shoes and Bisleri bottle. As we joined the last leg of the Yatra, there was a traffic jam. There seemed to be more vehicles than walkers, more chaos than rebellion. There were trucks, motorbikes, VIP cars, police vans, rickshaws, camel carts, even a convertible and a trail of plastic cups. This didn’t seem like the Dandi March, it was the Dandi Jam. A far cry from the Mahatma’s defiant march through the villages of Gujarat, which was celebrated throughout the country and shook the British Empire. But, as we trudged though the exhaust fumes in the cavalcade and finally caught up with the Yatris, I realised that the trappings may have changed today and our country may not defy imperialism, but Gandhiji still lives within several people like Rajkumar, who have left everything to be here.

The Salt March 2005 was organised to celebrate the 75th anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi’s 386 km March from Sabarmati Ashram in Ahmedabad to Dandi in south Gujarat where he broke the salt laws and demanded Swaraj - complete freedom from British rule. During the 26 days of the walk, Gandhiji and his 78 marchers stopped at villages, lived and spoke with people. Government officials were asked to quit their jobs and join the Civil Disobedience movement. More than 227 did. Many people joined the march at various points. The entire country was abuzz and Satyagraha meetings were held in several places. Gandhi’s symbolic act of lifting salt from the beaches of Dandi inspired people to rebel against British rule.

Around 500 marchers in the Dandi Yatra 2005 re-traced his steps, stopping at the same places as the Mahatma. Trucks following them with tents, mattresses, cooking utensils, mobile toilets, generators and even an air-conditioned mobile internet van. Villagers lined the streets to greet them, offer them food and many fell at the feet of the Gandhi look-alike. The marchers were a motley crew - Seva Dal or Youth Congress volunteers, students from as far as Sikkim and Hawaii, freedom fighters from Peshawar, people from Australia, the US, China and die-hard Gandhi followers like Rajkumar.

Rangitbhai Baria walked the entire distance bare-foot. “I wanted to tell the world that by doing penance, you can attain anything,” said the elderly Rangitbhai, with a spring in his step and a smile in his eyes. Rangitbhai, a small farmer and social worker from Panchmahal district in Gujarat, said, “I’ve always wanted to walk in the footsteps of Bapuji and this march was the perfect opportunity.” Rangitbhai and Rajkumar became close friends during the march. “I made friends with this man, who is a gem of a person, sings such lovely songs. I don’t want to be separated from him,” said Rajkumar.

When I met him, Turab Ali Bohra (75) was searching for an ambulance at night. “I have blisters and am not feeling well. It’s too hot to eat, there’s no place to sleep,” he said. Turab, a retired plumber, travelled alone from Devas in M.P. for the march. “In my old age, there’s no better joy than being part of Gandhiji’s march. The people of Gujarat have shown us so much love, I can’t imagine there was so much violence in the state three years back.”

A group of 92 Pakistani students and elders from the Awami Party, a movement started by Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan a.k.a. The Frontier Gandhi walked the entire distance. Shahid Alam, leader of the Pakhtoon Students Federation said that they were overwhelmed by the welcome they received from ordinary Indians. “Common people on both sides want peace. It’s only the politicians and fundamentalists that keep us apart. If both countries reduced our defence budgets and concentrated on development instead, we would both prosper,” he said. “The sacrifices our ancestors made should not go in vain. Both Gandhiji and Bacha Khan fought imperialism, and we should follow their path.”

Following the yatra on his motorbike was award-winning US director of the film Woodstock, Mike Wadleigh. “What struck me during this journey is that there are so many signs around that show the Americanisation of India. Too many people want India to become like America,” he said. “But the US is not the solution. It is the cause for so many of the problems in the world today. It consumes 30% of all the world’s products though it has only 4% of the population. If we were all to be like America, we would need eight planet Earths.”

In some sections of the media and amongst a few of the yatris, there was criticism that the Congress(I) Party sponsored the event and turned it into a massive roadshow. But the truth is that Gandhi’s yatra was political, and he was a Congress leader. The salt satyagraha was part of the Congress’ Civil Disobedience movement. The party would be foolish if it weren’t affiliated with such an event today.

The yatra may not have been held if not for the Congress(I). Tushar Gandhi, organiser of the event and also Gandhiji’s great grandson, could not find any sponsors and hence approached the Congress(I). They took care of a large part of the expenses, their volunteers and party workers arranged for food and accommodation at every stop. The Yatris, foreign or Indian, didn’t have to pay a penny.

The start and end of the Yatra were particularly chaotic since Congress(I) president Sonia Gandhi, accompanied by heavy security, joined the march. The day after the march ended, the Congress(I) held a huge public meeting on the shores of Dandi attended by Mrs. Gandhi and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. The rally had an estimated two to three lakh crowd, one of the biggest ever witnessed in Gujarat, far greater than the BJP’s various Ram Yatras and Modi’s Gaurav Yatra. Only the Mahatma’s name could attract such a vast gathering. The entire road to Dandi was jammed, the beach crowded. People coming in trucks couldn’t reach in time for the meeting. In Gujarat, where the Congress(I) is weak compared to the BJP, the response to the yatra made the BJP nervous. On the day after the yatra left Sabarmati Ashram , the BJP swept and washed the ashram to ‘purify and cleanse’ it after the Congress’ yatris set foot inside.

Sonia Gandhi at Dandi 2005

“Why shouldn’t the Congress(I) be part of this march? In Gujarat, if we want to defeat communal forces like the BJP, the only legitimate force is the Congress(I),” said Tushar Gandhi. But isn’t it hypocritical that a party implementing policies that welcome imperialism should be sponsoring the Dandi March, which was held to defy foreign domination and assert independence? “Some people may call it tokenism but such marches help us focus on certain ideals. It reminds people and makes them aware of what Gandhi stood for. I couldn’t believe it when people would stop their cars on the road and rush to touch the feet of our Gandhi look-alike,” said Tushar Gandhi.

The Dandi March 2005 may have been chaotic, some might call it a Gandhian ritual, but the goodwill it generated and the crowds it attracted proves that in the hearts of thousands like Rajkumar, the Mahatma lives on.

Frontline April 23 - May 6, 2005 Also available here


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------


In the Mahatma's footsteps

Conversation with Shantibhai Sakarchand Shah (83), a satyagrahi from Anand, Gujarat

"I am not going to criticise this march. It’s good that new people come to know who Gandhi was. They know about Amitabh Bachchan but they know nothing about the father of the nation, Mahatma Gandhi. This march may be a drama or whatever, but at least it has triggered interest in children.

It was said that the sun never set on the British empire. Gandhi didn’t even use a stick, but the British feared him. He instilled the thought that man is born free and that we will take Swaraj, our birthright, there is no need to ask for our rights.
When I was six years old, Bapu came to our village in 1928. My sister went and garlanded him to welcome him. In 1930, he went for the Salt Satyagraha. Our mother took us on the bullock cart to watch him pass by. We all dressed up in khadi and went.

I enrolled as a satyagrahi when I was 16. When I was 20, I came home from the college where I was studying. My mother was surprised to see me back home halfway through the term. She asked me, ‘What happened?’ I asked her for her blessings to go to Gandhi’s ashram. Everyone in the village told her, ‘You are sending your young son to die’. She said, ‘they are not doing anything wrong’.

I went to Bardoli, where Bapu and Sardar had come to register people. He said, ‘From now on, you won’t have any land or home. Our nation is very poor, our people don’t have anything. You will have to teach children, make sure people don’t fight amongst themselves. And, what they give you, you will eat. Wherever they put you up, you will sleep.’

I was at Gowalia Tank in Bombay when the Quit India resolution was passed. It was Do or Die. Nothing else. I was put in jail.
We were not freedom fighters. We were people who followed the leaders like Gandhi, Nehru, Sardar Patel. We are satyagrahis.

I don’t believe in isms. I don’t think of myself of a Gandhian or anything like that, I follow the path of truth. Gandhi said, ‘I have come to teach people nothing new, truth and non-violence are as old as the hills.’ There’s nothing to teach, everyone knows that is truth and what isn’t.

Gandhi wanted to teach people to say no, to give them courage. That they could do things. But how? Gandhi showed the road that the entire country could follow. Boycott British goods, give up government jobs, refuse to go to court. There was new hope that we can fight. When he broke the salt law, people got strength, courage to break the law all over the country. In every house, people were making salt. The atmosphere was transformed.

Only when the poorest are happy, then we can be free and life begins.

When people ask me, where do you stay, I say I am nowhere. It has two meanings: nowhere and now here. I left home when I was 20 and since then have never had a home."

Frontline April 23 - May 6, 2005 Also available here

----------------------------

The Salt Satyagraha, 12th March to 6th April 1930.

On 26th January 1930, the Indian National Congress led by Gandhi and Nehru issued a Declaration of Independence and decided to launch a mass Civil Disobedience movement. Gandhi decided to make the salt tax the rallying point for the satyagraha, as salt was an essential commodity and the salt tax on it affected all classes, especially the poor. The salt tax gave the British government a monopoly on the production and sale of salt. It was a criminal offence for anyone else to produce salt. Even though salt was readily available on the coast, people could not pick it up and consume it.

Before setting out on his march, Gandhiji sent the Viceroy a letter asking him to revoke the law, but it had no effect. On March 12, 1930, he set out from Sabarmati Ashram in Ahmedabad with 78 other male satyagrahis on a 386 km walk to Dandi. Hundreds joined them while they walked. En route, they stopped at villages and mobilised people for the civil disobedience movement. They encouraged government employees to quit their jobs, students to leave school and college and join the revolution. In villages along the way, 227 villages headmen resigned from their jobs. Gandhiji told them that the salt satyagraha was only one battle on the road to Swaraj (self rule). All over the country, meetings were held in response to the march, salt was produced, British goods were boycotted.
Photo: Mahatma Gandhi Foundation

“Today we are defying the salt law. Tomorrow we shall have to consign other laws to the waste paper basket. Doing so we shall practise such severe non-cooperation that finally it will not be possible for the administration to be carried on at all. Let the government then carry on its rule, use guns against us, send us to prison, hang us. But how many can be given such punishment? Try and calculate how much time it will take a lakh of Britishers to hang 30 crore persons,” said the Mahatma.

On 6th April, they reached the shores of Dandi where Gandhi picked up a handful of sand and salt and said, “With this, I am shaking the foundations of the British Empire.” His satyagrahis then boiled sea water to make salt, which was later auctioned for the cause.

The British government spent weeks deliberating whether they should arrest Gandhi. Finally, he was arrested in Karadi, a village near Dandi on 4th May.

(Sources: www.mahatma.org.in, www.mkgandhi.org, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page)

Frontline April 23 - May 6, 2005 Also available here

Private water, public thirst

Maharashtra’s first experiment in privatisation of drinking water supply has left Chandrapur high and dry

DIONNE BUNSHA
in Chandrapur, Maharashtra
"Whom should I ask today?" This thought plays on Swarta Shende's mind soon after she wakes up. It's another bright morning. Another day fretting about how she will fill the 20 pots of water her family needs. Many women like Swarta have to worry about borrowing water everyday in Chandrapur town.

"The public tap has water for only two hours a day. And, with so many women scrambling for their share, I get only three pots from here," says Swarta. "Then, I go to other peoples' homes - those who have their own taps or wells, asking if they will let me to fill a few pots." Swarta tries not to go too often to the same place or they may get irritated. She hopes she hasn't caught them in a foul mood. If they haven't fought with their husband or their children haven't played up, it makes life easier for Swarta as well. "Two hours of my day is spent just collecting water," she says.

Photo: Ranjit Deshmukh
It wasn't always this bad. "Earlier, we got water from 1 p.m. to 6 p.m. That was enough for everyone. But a year back, they cut it down to two hours, so now we have to borrow from others," Swarta explains. Why has the water supply been reduced? She has no idea. But the water cuts seem to coincide with the time when the town's water distribution was privatised in March 2004. Of course, Swarta doesn't know that her municipal council handed over water provision to a contractor. She's only struggling with the after-effects.

Chandrapur is the first town in Maharashtra to privatise its water supply to 'improve efficiency and investment'. The municipal council wanted to cut the 'losses' they were incurring to run the water supply scheme. Sheikh Maqsood, city engineer of Chandrapur Municipal Council (CMC), who was one of the municipal officials involved in the privatisation tender process, told Frontline, "We aimed to recover at least Rs 1.46 crore as water tax, but we were able to recover only half that amount. Our expenses were Rs 3 crore every year, and we were making huge losses. So, we decided that it was better to hand it over to a private company, since the Maharashtra government has allowed privatisation schemes."

The deal: the CMC will get Rs 1.59 crores (over a period of ten years) and a Rs 75 lakh bank guarantee for handing over water distribution to Gurukripa Associates. The CMC retains ownership of the network. But the company takes over distribution, maintenance and water tax collections for ten years. The contractor has to build only one km of new pipeline every year. Any improvements and investments in the network is the CMC's responsibility. It may cut the CMC's losses. But how has it affected the town's residents? Has it made water supply more 'efficient'? Has investment increased?

Here are snatches of our conversations with Chandrapur's residents. As we travelled through this grimy industrial town, people in different neighbourhoods - right from what they call the 'VIP areas' to the slum colonies - said that water supply had worsened. And there's no response to their complaints.

Ratnamala Nagarkar from Vadgaon, Sai Baba ward, says water supply has reduced to a trickle and she has to keep guessing whether there will be water tomorrow. "We used to get water twice a day. Now we get it only in the afternoon for three hours," she says. "The flow in our public tap is much less so it takes longer to fill. Often, there's no water for two or three days, so we have to be careful and always keep aside some pots in case there is no water the next day." Many like Ratnamala don't know they have been made guinea pigs in Chandrapur's water privatisation experiment.
Supply to many public taps has been stopped. The poorest, who depend on these taps, have been worst hit. The government has issued a notification that no new public standposts should be built. Instead, efforts should be made to have group connections to make people share the water bill.

"Four taps in our area are not functioning. They refuse to repair it. We can't afford to have our own water taps. Only one in six houses has their own connection," said Prahlad Kamte, a resident of Indira Nagar in Mela ward. Girish Chandak, director of Gurukripa Associates told Frontline, "Every few days, the taps of the public taps get stolen, and water is wasted as it flows out of the pipe. So, instead we are trying to get people to pay for group connections. It's the government's policy. If you give water for free, people don't value it."

Many who have water supply at home have got fed up and let the company disconnect their connection. "We haven't got tap water for almost two years. So we let them stop our supply. It doesn't make any difference to us," said D.S. Khanke, a retired forest dept. employee. "We dug our own borewell so that we don't have to rely on them."

"This is a man-made shortage. There's enough drinking water for the entire city from the Irai dam nearby, but there's no network to supply it to people," says Sanjay Vaidya, municipal councillor. Chandrapur's water network hasn't expanded since the mid-1960s. As the town has grown, several new neighbourhoods that have come up over the years don't have municipal water supply. They rely on their own private borewells.

While Sanjay Vaidya estimates that 60 per cent of Chandrapur’s three lakh population are not part of the water pipeline network, city engineer Sheikh Maqsood says 30 per cent are left out. The water table is falling as more borewells are dug, most without permission from the CMC. Due to this declining water table, the CMC has decided not to dig any more borewells, but it keeps no check on the proliferation of private wells. Plans to enhance the distribution network have been stalled because the CMC doesn't have the funds to guarantee the loans granted for the project.

Photo: Ranjit Deshmukh

After hearing complaints from all corners of the town, we met Girish Chandak, the company's director, who explained, "We have tried to balance out water supply so that places that didn't get water are now getting it, and those areas which had five hours of water, or even 24 hours, now receive less. The people you met must have been getting water for longer, that's why they were complaining."

Refuting complaints that services were worse because the company did not spend on maintenance, he said, "We have put in Rs 3 crore to streamline the whole system. There was no proper maintenance or records earlier, and there was a lot of corruption and delay in repair works. There are regular leakages because pipelines near the coal mines burst often due to blasting. We repair them within six hours, while the CMC would take six days."

Chandak added that the municipality used to get 150 complaints a day while his company gets just five. He also pointed out that five years back, the CMC had 24,000 connections, which dropped to 17,000 in 2004 when the company took over. "Today, it is 19,000. That is enough proof. If there was no proper water supply, people would not take a new connection," he said.

Questions have also been raised about the Gurukripa's track record. It was formed only to bid for the tender and has no experience in water management. Its partners are powerful traders in the city - oil merchants, builders, medicine distributors and even liquor barons.

The nexus was clear when we met the city engineer. Within ten minutes of knowing we were in town, he found out all the places we had visited. For our interview, he invited us to a councillor's house, the head of the planning committee. While we were talking, he sent word to Chandak, who immediately showed up at the councillor's house, though we were supposed to meet him at this office later. The close ties between politicians, bureaucrats and businessmen here could not have been made more evident.

The people of Chandrapur weren’t given a choice between public or private irregularities. They can only decide who they will borrow water from today.

Frontline, April 8 - 21, 2006 Also available here