Showing posts with label Environment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Environment. Show all posts

Gone with the Waves

As the sea eats into the coast of south Gujarat, fishing villages are ruined.

DIONNE BUNSHA

Villagers with bricks retrieved from their old homes in Danti.
Photo: Dionne Bunsha

Danti is being invaded. More than half the residents have already fled this sleepy fishing village. But it isn't guns and troops that they are running away from. The sea that they revere and fish in has swallowed up the village, making people retreat further back every year.

Only the poorest remain on the edge of the village, with just a sea wall for protection. On one side of the wall are lashing waves. And, on the other are ramshackle, makeshift huts. No one here has permanent brick homes. They have to rebuild every year, after the waters rush in over the wall. The ocean knows no boundaries.

Govindbhai Tandel is the first to face its fury. His hut lies at the tip of the village, closest to the seafront, unprotected even by the stone wall. Govindbhai is back home after eight months at sea on his fishing boat. He returns to Danti in Valsad district during the monsoon, when it's too rough to go out to fish. But there's no rest at home. His family is hard at work filling their porch with sand, trying to elevate the entrance to prevent the tide from coming in. There's not much they can do. Water will flood their home anyways. It's only damage control.

"We have moved back three kilometers in the last 20 years. Our original village was out there – 3 km in the sea. You can't even see it now," says Govindbhai. "Three village wells have been submerged. We've relocated the school thrice. I've shifted home thrice so far. Can you see out there? That's where my last house was," he says pointing to a distant spot in the sea.

The village is long gone but lives on memory. As we walked around the village, most people pointed to various landmarks – all in the water. Nostalgia is the only thing that remains. During low tide, the beach is a hive of activity. Families are hard at work, trying to salvage bricks from the ruins of their old homes.

Salvaging the remains of homes that were submerged by the sea
Photo: Dionne Bunsha

On the sea shore is a brick wall with an arch - the remnants of Damentiben Tandel's house. "It broke three years back. Since then, we have kept moving and rebuilding every year," she says. "When the water comes in every monsoon, it's knee-high. Then, we have to put our kids on the roof in the pouring rain. We don't have the money to buy land and move out, so we remain here."

There's often water in their homes, but none to drink. "Our wells are in the sea. We get drinking water from the tap once every week or 15 days. Otherwise, we have to buy water. Tempos come here and deliver. It's Rs 30 for a barrel that lasts one day," says Damentiben.

Danti is on the coast of south Gujarat, one of the most industrialized areas in the country. It's called the 'Golden Corridor', but has some of the country's worst polluted spots like Ankleshwar and Vapi. Close to Danti is Dandi, the site of Gandhi's historic Salt March. This coast is now colonized by chaotic and toxic industrialization.

A house ravaged by the sea at Kaladra in Bharuch district.
Photo: Dionne Bunsha

"The fish have gone further out in the sea because of pollution. And, the water has come further in, so we have suffered. We can't go very far in our tiny boats. We used to get 400 to 600 fish in one night . Now we barely get a hundred," says Shantibhai Tandel, a small fisherman. He has shifted back six times and is now in his seventh house. "I want my kids to study. The only thing is we can't afford donations for their education or bribes to get them a job. If they are lucky, they will find a job, otherwise they will have to stay here, continue fishing and face the hardships." Sandwiched between the sea and salt pans, there's not much further back they can retreat.

Many from the village have moved to other towns or to Dandi 12 km away in the last 7-8 years. But like Mahesh Hari Tandel, those who moved for safety still yearn for the sea. "My boat is still in Danti and I feel I have to go there everyday," he says. "When my father was alive, we shifted our house four times. After he died, our house broke twice and then we moved here. After we lost the mangroves in the last 15 to 20 years, many people had to migrate to big port towns like Mumbai, Porbandar or Veraval to work. Earlier, we could survive by fishing closeby and in the mangroves."

Jayantibhai Rathod repairs his fishing net at New Kaladra, where he resettled after the fishing colony at Kaladra was submerged 15 years ago.
Photo: Dionne Bunsha

No one knows for sure why the sea is eroding the coast at such an alarmingly voracious pace. One of the reasons could be a rise in sea level due to global warming. Without even knowing what 'global warming' means, villagers along this coast are 'environmental refugees'. Though they are barely surviving, they are facing the brunt of reckless consumption in more affluent places. Ironically, most of these villages haven't been provided electric meters. People illegally tap electricity from the power cables that run above their homes. They don't know what global warming means. Many of them could not explain why the sea was advancing. Some fishermen guessed that it might be "because there are more storms in the sea."

Geologists from the M.S. University, Vadodara are studying the Gujarat coastline part of an all-India study by the Space Application Centre, ISRO. "Our preliminary observations reveal that the seawater has shifted in by 10-15 meters in 10 years, and at places it has moved around 80 meters horizontally," says Dr Nikhil Desai, who is heading the survey of the Gujarat coast. They are comparing recent satellite images with older Survey of India maps prepared in the '60s, and have observed that the coastline of Gujarat is changing shape.

Several places along India's 7,500 km long coastline are experiencing similar erosion. In the Sunderbans, two islands have already vanished from the map displacing 7,000 people. Twelve more islands are likely to go under due to an annual 3.14 mm sea level rise, which will make 70,000 people refugees. Five villages in Orissa's Bhitarkanika National Park, famous for mass nesting of Olive Ridley turtles, have also submerged, and 18 others are likely to go under. India is one of 27 countries identified by the UN as most vulnerable to the impacts of global warming related sea level rise.

"Observations suggest that the sea level has risen at a rate of 2.5 mm per year along the Indian coastline since the 1950s. A mean sea level rise of between 15 and 38 cm is projected by the middle of the century along India's coast. Added to this, a 15% projected increase in intensity of tropical cyclones would significantly enhance the vulnerability of populations in cyclone prone coastal regions," according to Dr. Murari Lal, a renowned climatologist engaged in research related to climate change vulnerability analysis in India. Dr Lal has been one of the lead authors of the UN's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) reports for over 15 years, which collates research about climate change from scientific work across the world.

Children help in raising the level of Govindbhai Tandel's house in Danti as the family braces itself for the onslaught of the monsoon.
Photo: Dionne Bunsha

"No local studies have been done in India to measure the precise impact of global warming. But, in the last decade, several factors have contributed to the loss of coastal land due to sea level rise," says Dr Murari Lal. "Arctic ice has melted three times faster than predicted by the IPCC in 2001. Sea level has risen twice more than projected by the climate models. Stronger surface winds and storms have resulted in higher waves, which reach further inland. Human interventions like the removal of mangroves, reclamation and construction along the coast have also led to faster erosion of the coast."

"Sea rise due to global warming could be just one of the reasons for the erosion along the Gujarat coast," says Dr Desai. "Local factors could also be responsible. Neo-tectonic activities - shifts in the level of the sea bed - could also cause the sea level to rise. If there are disturbances in sediment budgeting along the coast, the amount of deposits from rivers, it could also affect the water level." Their study will determine which of these reasons is driving the changes along the coast.

Further north, at the estuary of the river Narmada, Kaladra village in Bharuch district is also being nibbled away by the sea. Several houses are half-broken, hanging on the edge of a cliff of sand that can cave in at any point. A sea wall built twenty years back is now a relic of the past. A road constructed two years back (at a cost of Rs 30 lakh) has been cut like a cake by the lashing waves. "The poorest are the most directly affected by this. Most families here are in a dilemma. They can't afford to shift but they cannot stay here either," said Dr Desai.

A road built two years ago near Kaladra village has been eroded. A sea wall (in the foreground) offered little protection.
Photo: Dionne Bunsha

Kaladra too has been half-abandoned. The Rathod fishing colony here was washed away around 20 years back. They resettled in 'New Kaladra', just a little higher up the estuary. The fisherfolk have been here for long, but their houses are still temporary. Here too, there's no escape from the advancing water. "For around six days every monsoon, the water is waist deep. Then, we bring our boats to the doorstep, and fill all our stuff in it," says Jayantibhai Rathod, a fisherman.

An eroded road in Kaladra.
Photo: Dionne Bunsha

When fishermen are forced to run away from sea, when they don't want their sons to continue their trade, its time to start worrying. "This is a land of sand so you can never tell when it will shift," says Shantibhai Tandel from Danti. "We will keep moving back as far as we can. Then, it's in the hands of destiny." It's total surrender to the forces of nature. But how much of nature's fury has been due to the recklessness of other men? The people of Danti and Kaladra are too busy surviving the onslaught of the sea to dwell on the actions of others. It's the last thing on their mind as they sit on their rooftops in the pouring rain.

WEBLINKS:

- Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change: http://www.ipcc.ch/

- Reducing risks to cities from disasters and climate change by Saleemul Huq, Sari Kovats, Hannah Reid and David Satterthwaite, Environment & Urbanisation, Vol 19 No 1, April 2007.http://www.iied.org/human/eandu/documents/EU19_editorial.pdf

- India’s National Communication to the UNFCC
http://www.natcomindia.org

Frontline, Jul. 14-27, 2007 Also available here

Bt rice trials uprooted

DIONNE BUNSHA

By uprooting Bt rice trials in Tamil Nadu, farm activists and Greenpeace have stirred up the debate on GM food testing. And they have support from unlikely quarters - rice exporters.

The tranquil routine of Rangaraju’s retired life was in for a rude shock. On the morning of 10th November, people from the Tamil Nadu Farmers Association landed up at his doorstep. They wanted to uproot the harvest in his paddy farm. The farmers told him his rice field had a genetically modified crop whose harvest could contaminate food supplies if it was not destroyed.

A bewildered Rangaraju didn’t know how to react. He asked them for time to consult Mahyco, the company that was conducting a field trial in his plot. But before he knew it, the 150-odd people in the crowd had uprooted the Bt rice crop from his field in Ramanathapuram village near Coimbatore in Tamil Nadu. In a matter of one day, this unassuming retired schoolteacher found himself in the midst of an international controversy over genetically engineered crops.

“We didn’t know what kind of rice they were growing,” Hemalata, his daughter, told Frontline. “My father signed an agreement with the company, but didn’t study it carefully. We thought it was a hybrid seed, we didn’t know it was something different.” Hemalata’s family feels cheated. “It is fraud by the company. They did not tell us much. Let’s hope it will not put our next crop in danger.”

Rangaraju is not alone. Last month, the Bharatiya Kissan Union (BKU) burned the harvest of Bt rice trials in two farms in Haryana and Uttar Pradesh. In Rampura village in Karnal district of Haryana, they burned the field to prevent contamination. When they reached Rudrapur village, Gorakhpur district in UP, BKU activists got the police to seize the grain that was lying in the plot. Along with Panchayat president of the village, they filed a police complaint against Mahyco, the Department of Biotechnology and the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee, for several violations found in a GM Rice trial plot.

Here too, the farmers and the panchayat were not aware of that the seeds were genetically modified and had no clue of the likely dangers of growing them in their fields. They had merely leased out the land to Mahyco and signed the agreements without knowing what genetically modified actually means. The company is conducting 10 field trials of Bt rice in six states across the country.


"They are toying with farmers’ ignorance about GM technology,” said Rakesh Tikait, spokesperson of the BKU. “Knowing the unreliable track record of the company and the state regulators, we had to destroy the crop to prevent contamination from the trial plots into the food supply chain where unwary consumers are eating untested products. This is all the more dangerous in a Basmati rice growing belt of the country. The department of Biotechnology’s guidelines require destruction of the GM plant material after the trial. By burning the crop, we have made sure these guidelines are not flouted."

Bt rice is a genetically engineered seed designed to make the crop resistant to pests like stem borer and leaf folder. The seeds are created by inserting a synthetic version of a gene (called Cry1Ac) from a naturally occurring soil bacterium called bacillus thuringiensis (bt) into the plant’s DNA so the plant creates its own toxin to destroy the pests. India has allowed the commercial sale of Bt cotton seeds, and the trials for Bt Brinjal are also underway.

In September this year, the Supreme court temporarily stopped the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) from granting permission for any more field trials for GM crops. The court was responding to a petition which pointed out several irregularities in the regulatory procedures. Currently, Indian rules allow field trials to start even before biosafety tests are completed. Moreover, monitoring of these trials are extremely lax, almost non-existent.

The petition also pointed out the inherent conflict of interest evident in the constitution of regulatory authorities. Senior office-bearers and members of the GEAC are also part of biotech industry-promoted bodies or are crop developers themselves in their personal or institutional capacities. Currently around 150 trials for GE food crops are underway ranging from brinjal to tomato, mustard, maize and of course, rice.

No country in the world has cleared the commercial sale of Bt rice. The impacts on human health have not yet been fully tested. A recent study in Madhya Pradesh found that farm workers exposed to Bt cotton had allergies – skin eruptions, swollen faces. Moreover, the Bt toxin can enter the human digestive system and interfere with the bacteria in the intestines.

The Cry1Ac gene is a powerful immunogen and can prompt adverse reactions from the immune system. Studies worldwide have shown that eating GM food could result in wasteful growth of gut tissues and bacterial proliferation, intestinal tumours, immune system suppression, interference with the development of the body’s vital organs and reproduction. Earlier this year, there were mass deaths of cattle grazing on the remains in harvested Bt cotton fields in Warangal district in Andhra Pradesh.

GM plants could harm the environment and biodiversity. Once out in the fields, there is no way of knowing whether normal plant varieties have been contaminated by the GM variety through pollination, which could lead to the extinction of local crop varieties. Moreover, there is also a danger that insects could develop resistance to the toxin, after which more pesticides would be needed to get rid of them.

Farmers groups aren’t alone in their protest against GM crops. Recently, rice exporters held a press conference with Greenpeace demanding that the government halt field trials. They are worried that if there is any contamination, it could harm exports. In August this year, US rice exports were adversely affected when it was found that certain consignments contained GM contaminated rice. The US Department of Agriculture (USDA) admitted that a variety of Bayer’s Liberty Link rice that was not approved for consumption or cultivation in the world (LL rice 601) had been detected in rice intended for export. This raised an alarm in the EU and Japan and adversely affected US rice trade. Indian exporters are scared that our exports could be similarly harmed if there is even a slight doubt of contamination.

“It is shocking and unfortunate that the government is allowing even small-scale, field trials of GE rice in the Basmati-growing region. This is a matter of grave concern for all Basmati rice exporters from this region," said Brigadier Anil Adlakha, Executive Director of the All-India Rice Exporters Association (AIREA). “Any contamination from GE rice field trials will be a death knell for millions of farmers and exporters. We want the government to draw the correct lesson from the plight of the US rice industry and stop further GE rice field trials in this region now. If the government doesn’t heed our warning, it could prove to be a costly and irreversible blunder.”

Greenpeace recently found that GE rice from field trials in China had found its way into imported Chinese rice products in France, Germany and the UK. Indian exporters are afraid our trade will suffer if any part of the harvest from field trials in India finds its way into food supplies. At present, India exports 400 million tones of rice worth Rs 700 crores.

Activists from the Tamil Nadu Farmers Association destroying a GE rice trial crop in Ramanathapuram, 20 km from Coimbatore
Photo: Greenpeace

“Why are they so concerned about exports? We should think of filling our own bellies first. Bt rice will help increase productivity by reducing crop damage due to pest attacks,” M.K. Sharma, managing director of MAHYCO told Frontline. As much as 20% of yield could be lost due to the stem borer pest, which Bt rice guards against, he added. Sharma said that Bt cotton sales have been rising exponentially every year because farmers find them effectively. However, he dodged the fact that the places in Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh where Bt cotton use is amongst the highest are also the areas where farmers suicides are the most.

Outraged at the protests on MAHYCO’s field trials, Sharma said, “These people are preventing technology from reaching farmers. They are standing in the way of scientific research. While testing is still underway, how can they say that the crop is dangerous? They have done this for cheap publicity and we have filed a police complaint against them for damaging our trial crop.” He countered the allegation that proper norms were not adhered to. “We have followed all the rules, keeping a 20-metre isolation around the field to prevent pollination outside. The question of contamination does not arise as we were about to burn the field as per the regulations so that there is no trace of any plant material. Moreover, the farmers had full knowledge of the trial. They signed agreements with us in which all the conditions were laid out.”

Environmental and agricultural research groups insist that they too were asking for scientific and transparent research. “While dealing with such technology, we have to follow the precautionary principle,” said Kavitha Kuruganti from the Centre for Sustainable Agriculture, Hyderabad. “Until independent scientific laboratory studies show that this crop is safe for human consumption, the government should not allow any field trials to take place.” At present, the biosafety testing is done by the company itself.

Even though signatures were taken, field trials were conducted without warning the plot owners about the environmental hazards. “Contamination can take place even beyond the isolation distance. State and local authorities weren’t informed either. Regulatory agencies are not monitoring the field trials properly,” Ms Kuruganti said. During field trials of Bt cotton and Bt brinjal, it was found that untested products from the trials were being sole in the local market, she added.

Often GE technology is pushed as the solution to India’s food security problem. However, environmental groups challenge this assumption, asserting that there are several other indigenous plant varieties that can boost farm productivity. “The real solutions for sustainable rice production already exist in farms around the world. They are based on traditional knowledge combined with cutting-edge technology, and are far more reliable and acceptable than destructive industrial agriculture and imprecise genetic engineering,” said Nammalwar, a well-known organic farming scientist from India.

“The world’s most important staple crop is too important to gamble with. There are as many as 140,000 different varieties of rice, with an enormous diversity of traits, such as resistance to different pests and diseases and capacity to grow in salty or dry conditions,” said Divya Raghunandan from Greenpeace India. “We don’t need genetic engineering to take advantage of these traits – we need to preserve this resource and knowledge and combine it with safe hi tech breeding techniques.” Greenpeace has just released a report called ‘The Future of Rice’ by scientists Dr Emerlito Borromes and Dr Debal Deb which explains that GE technology is unnecessary since other more sustainable options exist to increase rice yields.

Judging by the way field trials are being conducted, it seems like it’s not only the farmers like Rangaraju on whose plots the tests are underway, but also the Indian public, who are left in the dark, clueless of the dangers that GE technology could unleash.

Frontline, Nov. 18-Dec. 01, 2006 Also available here

Back to the Basics

DIONNE BUNSHA

Organic farming is not the only solution to the problems contributing to the farm crisis. However, it is the only one within the farmer's control.

WITHIN THEIR CONTROL: Farmers can get the same or a better yield without spending on pesticide and fertilizer.
Photo: Dionne Bunsha


While hordes of media swamped Vidarbha just before the PM's visit, I was there with two agricultural scientists Vipin and Devang on a different trip.

Vipin and Devang are from Sristi, an organisation that works to develop eco-friendly solutions to local problems. They have a long-term remedy to the farm crisis, one that will go beyond the temporary relief that the PM has doled out. Yes, immediate action is important. It may prevent several suicides. The PM's interest waiver and re-scheduling of bank loans will give people much-needed loans to sow their next crop of cotton and soyabean. But then what? What happens at the end of the season when they can't pay off their loans once again?

Crux of the crisis
They will be in the same dilemma simply because the cost of farming is higher than the pathetic price they receive for their inputs. That is the crux of the farm crisis — spiralling costs, miserable prices. In the last 10 years, the cost of living has risen dramatically, but the price of cotton has fallen. That's why the rural economy is collapsing. All the other symptoms — inadequate bank credit, exploitative moneylenders, the unscrupulous input traders, illness, school dropouts — are aggravated by this basic problem.

There is not much farmers can do to change government policy that determines output prices, trade tariffs, social security and subsidies. That is beyond their control. But the one thing farmers can do is to try and reduce costs of cultivation.

That's where Sristi has a plan. They have developed and verified several indigenous, organic farming practices that have worked. Farmers can get the same or a better output without spending a penny on pesticides and fertilizers. All they have to do is prepare organic pesticide, fertilizer and growth promoters from plants and other material available in their own environment. There's no need for them to depend on a shop owner and get entangled in a web of exploitation and debt.

"In fact, the solution is simple," says Prof. Anil Gupta, founder of Sristi. "Why spend so much resources on pesticides? Go along with animal rearers in your area and look for plants that animals do not eat. These plants are the potential source of pesticides, because animals do not eat them; the toxicity inherent in them." Sristi tries to document, develop and share local solutions, ones that farmers have invented.

Several tried and tested organic techniques may save farmers from the clutches of trader-moneylenders. For instance, farmers can use the whey from buttermilk as a growth promoter. You don't need Bt seeds to ward off the bollworm; you can use whey or lantana extract. This is a two-in-one solution — you control lantana weed and at the same time get a local cheap pesticide. Calotripis or many other such plants found abundantly around the field, uneaten by animals, can be sprayed or even mixed with irrigation water. Farmers in different parts of Gujarat and other states have developed these techniques.

Contrary to popular misconceptions, organic farming doesn't mean low productivity. The output is the same or sometimes more than that of others who use chemical inputs. Sristi makes sure each method they advocate has first been tested scientifically by an independent research organisation before it suggests that farmers adopt the technique.

We met a bunch of farmers in Wardha who have switched to organic cultivation. They are not as anxious as most other farmers here who illogically douse their fields with pesticide and fertilizer. They don't have to worry about how they will get a loan, or how much pesticide to buy in the coming season. Most farmers dread the end of the season — it's payback time. But organic farmers look forward to a good crop that they can sell at the price they choose, not that dictated by exploitative moneylenders.

Pramod Kadam, a farmer and agricultural consultant from Wardha, is still paying off a huge debt he accumulated while using chemical inputs on his 15-acre field. "Now that I have switched to organic cotton cultivation, my costs have reduced from Rs. 5,000-8,000 an acre to around Rs. 3,000 an acre (for seeds, hiring bullock carts and wages for labourers). My yield is higher. The average here is around 2.5 quintals per acre, but I get four." So, he has saved on costs and gained in productivity.

Switch to organic
Many small farmers are apprehensive about the switch to organic. They feel it is too much of a risk, an experiment that can only be tried by big farmers or those who have irrigated land. But many of the organic farmers we met had small holdings. "Small farmers gain the most because we can't afford the high costs of cultivation. Big farmers can afford chemical cultivation," explained Sanjay Tigaonkar, an organic farmer from Wardha.

Organic farming is not the only solution to the problems contributing to the farm crisis. But it is the only one within the farmer's control. All other factors like prices, credit or irrigation are decided by a government that is more concerned about the Sensex than suicides. The farm crisis will continue until the Government decides to protect our farmers like the U.S. and EU protect theirs. Farmers in the EU are paid one dollar a day for every cow they rear — more than the daily wage of agricultural labourers in India. Until we protect our farmers, they will remain on the edge. Organic farming will definitely ease the burden of costs. But if that is not a viable route, will the government spend a fraction of the money it spends on promoting non-sustainable technologies on promotion of non-chemical alternatives?

Technical inputs
Besides monetary inputs, Vidarbha also needs technical inputs. If there were better agricultural advice, there may not have been such a dire demand for credit. There has been no competent agricultural guidance for decades. Few have thought of creative solutions. Even simple things like finding other sources of income like planting trees or rainwater harvesting in a region where only 11 per cent of farms are irrigated.

Until now the only technical advice has been from agriculture minister Sharad Pawar and film star Nana Patekar peddling Monsanto's Bt cottonseeds. Most people can't remember the last time they met an agricultural extension officer. So it's left to the input shop dealer to give advice, pushing the most expensive products to increase his sales.

Despite the massive failure of the Bt cotton crop last year (after which the Government had to compensate farmers), most people still opt for the seeds this year. Why? Simply because the company has lowered the price from Rs. 1,800 to Rs. 750. Now, it's only Rs. 200 cheaper than the hybrid variety. Might as well try it again. Though proven to be more effective, organic methods will never get the kind of hype that surrounds Bt cotton, simply because there is no money to be made from promoting self-reliance.

Vidarbha's crisis shows that we have gone full circle and it is time to go back to the basics. "India aspires to be a knowledge society but in agriculture, there is hardly any effort to draw upon our rich data base of agricultural practices (many of which have been compiled by Sristi for dissemination). How many sites exist where scientists are working with farmers' on their fields? We have to promote farmers' experimentation and innovations to generate sustainable solutions," says Prof. Gupta.

Sometimes the answers are right in front of us, but we can't see them because they are too simple.

For more information: Sristi

The Hindu Sunday Magazine July 16, 2006 Also available here

Biotech Brinjal

DIONNE BUNSHA

Union Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar had a rather unusual bunch of visitors last week - Greenpeace protesters dressed up as sheep and cattle, who camped outside his office. The "animals" were asking for an investigation into the death of 1,600 head of cattle and sheep in Andhra Pradesh in April 2006. The deaths were closely linked to prolonged consumption of Bt cotton stalks and leaves that were left in fields after the harvest.

Bt cotton is the only genetically modified (GM) seed sold in India. In the four years since it has been in use, not only has it failed to live up to its claim of being a `miracle seed', but it has also had harmful effects on biosafety.

At a time when the safety of Bt cotton is highly suspect, the government's Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) is considering clearance of large-scale field trials of Bt Brinjal. It is the first time that GM Brinjal is being released for an advanced stage of field trials in open conditions anywhere in the world. It is also the closest India has got to sanctioning GM food crops.

If cleared, it will be the first time that the GEAC allows large-scale field trials for GM food crops. Such field trials could lead to the uncontrolled release of genetically modified organisms into the environment, which could contaminate normal varieties of the crop. Japan and several European countries have banned cultivation of GM food crops. But India is allowing it entry without taking adequate precautions.

Greenpeace Activists demonstrate outside Union Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar's residence against GM agricultural products, in New Delhi on June 16.
Photo: S.Subramanium

Bt seeds are created by inserting a gene (Cry1Ac) from the soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis into a plant cell. This gene is supposed to protect the brinjal from insects such as the fruit and shoot borer. Bt cotton provides resistance to bollworm because the insect dies after eating the Bt toxin; the toxin disrupts its digestive process.

Biosafety tests for Bt brinjal started in 2002. After two years of greenhouse evaluation, Mahyco, the company producing the seed, started field trials in 11 locations with five hybrids in 2004. The results of the limited field trials have been posted on the GEAC website. The GEAC has invited public feedback before it decides whether to give clearance for large-scale field trials.

Several environmental groups and farmers' associations have appealed against the trials. But the GEAC is dismissive. "We would like some concrete objections based on the data placed before us by Mahyco, not general, emotional arguments," B.S. Parsheera, Chairperson of the GEAC, told Frontline. However, environmentalists opposing the trials say that the data are too sketchy to provide scientific feedback. "This shows how the GEAC takes decisions that affect the health of millions - based on meaningless presentations by companies," said Kavitha Kuruganti from the Centre for Sustainable Agriculture.

Top biotech scientists are also critical of the manner in which the GM tests are being conducted. "It is an absolute scandal for us to allow further trials despite the failure of Bt cotton. The seed should be withdrawn immediately, just like faulty drugs are removed from the market. We are being taken for a ride by the MNC [multinational company]-government nexus. These committees don't even have specialised scientists. They exist only to promote the interests of powerful companies, not of the country. And these MNCs, such as Monsanto which is promoting Bt seeds in India, have a notorious record all over the world," said Dr. Pushpa Bhargava, founder of the Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology, a world-renowned pioneer of genetic engineering in India.

"No country in the world has a satisfactory system of assessing the risks associated with the release of GM plants into the environment. What has happened in this extremely lax environment all over the world is extremely disturbing, " Bhargava explained. "It is shocking that no tests were done to monitor the effects on cattle or sheep if they ate the leaves of the Bt cotton plant, even though in India crop plants are often fed to cattle as fodder. That is why so many animals died in Andhra Pradesh. The main problem is that there is a conflict of interest in using the tests and data provided by the company."

The GEAC denies any such vested interest. "What vested interest? We are following all the norms laid down. Many institutes across the country are conducting the tests," said Parsheera.

The effects on human health are numerous and often unknown. A recent study in Madhya Pradesh found that farm workers exposed to Bt cotton had allergies including skin eruptions and swollen faces. The Cry1Ac gene is a powerful immunogen and can prompt adverse reactions from the immune system. If humans eat Bt brinjal it is possible that the Bt toxin can enter the human digestive system and interfere with the bacteria in the intestines. There are severe limitations to current allergy testing procedures for genetically modified organisms. Many GM crops such as beans and Starlink corn were found to produce allergies after they were sold in the market.

The NptII gene used as a marker in Bt brinjal can affect antibiotic resistance. The cauliflower mosaic virus, a viral promoter used in Bt brinjal, is similar to the hepatitis B virus, and could reactivate dormant viruses. Studies worldwide have shown that eating GM food can result in wasteful growth of gut tissues and bacterial proliferation, intestinal tumours, immune system suppression and interference with the development of the body's vital organs.

Mahyco, however, denied that there were any health risks. "Bt is no more immunogenic than any other protein that human and animals are exposed to," said Mahendra Sharma, managing director of Mahyco Monsanto Biotech and general manager of Mahyco. "It does not have any effect on the gut of mammals. It only kills insects. Studies have shown that if mammals consume 100mg of the toxin for every 1 kg of body weight, there is no adverse effect. We conducted tests on cooked Bt brinjal and they showed that the DNA disintegrated with the heat and there was no harmful effect. There is no risk of antibiotic resistance or risk of re-activating any viruses." None of Mahyco's claims has been verified independently, said Bhargava.

Genetically modified plants can harm the environment and biodiversity. Once out in the fields, there is no way of knowing whether normal plant varieties have been contaminated by the GM variety through pollination, which could lead to the extinction of local crop varieties. This is the reason for the `buffer zone' that most GM crops have rarely followed in India where land is scarce. Moreover, the Cry1Ac gene affects butterflies and moths and alters soil microbiology. Farmers using Bt cotton in India report decline in soil productivity. However, Mahyco said that its tests had ruled out the possibility of any such adverse impact on the environment.

Three varieties of the Bt cotton seed were denied permission of extension by the GEAC, based on the Andhra Pradesh government's analysis that their performance was inadequate. Two more varieties were banned by the Andhra Pradesh government after farmers' crops failed and the company refused to pay compensation. Yet, the GEAC feels that India needs GM technology. "We are far behind the rest of the world in biotechnology. We should catch up or we will face severe food security problems," said Parsheera.

"It is absurd to say that GM crops will bring us food security. Is there no food security in E.U. countries that have banned GM?" asked Bhargava. "It may kill biodiversity. Several organic methods of cultivation have proved far more effective," he said.

Field studies by the Deccan Development Society disproved many of the claims made about the advantages of using Bt Cotton. It is supposed to reduce expenses on pest management and increase productivity, but the study found that organic farmers had higher net returns and lower pest management costs.

The government is racing headlong into the genetic engineering maze, though agricultural studies are showing that natural processes are more effective. In just four years of GM technology, we have seen many disastrous results. Will no one listen as nature strikes back?

Frontline, June 17-30, 2006 Also available here

Dam lies

As Narmada River dams continue to rise, so too do the protests about the homes and livelihoods disappearing under dam waters... and the government lies about those who are displaced.

DIONNE BUNSHA

It started as just another VIP visit. With platoons of security guards, fleets of flashing cars and bowing bureaucrats in tow, three Ministers of the Indian Government were sent by the Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to assess whether villagers submerged by the Sardar Sarovar Project (SSP) – a huge dam on the Narmada river – had been resettled properly.

So the Ministers made their way from New Delhi, the capital, to Madhya Pradesh in central India, one of the three states affected by the project. The first stop: the red-carpet welcome by Madhya Pradesh’s chief minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan. He assured them that all project-affected families (PAFs) would be rehabilitated by 30 June 2006. On that optimistic note, Saifuddin Soz (Minister of Water Resources), Meira Kumar (Minister of Social Justice and Empowerment) and Prithviraj Chavan (from the Prime Minister’s office) set out to visit the submerging villages.

What they experienced shocked them. Their conversations with people at resettlement sites provoked them to write an honest, scathing report exposing the State Government’s lies. Their report – written confidentially – has just been published in The Hindu newspaper. The officials trailing the VIP team were silent. They couldn’t dispute what they saw.

Though the Supreme Court (SC) had ordered that families displaced by the dam must be compensated with land, the Madhya Pradesh Government had little land to give. To some, the Government had offered barren land. The team met only two families who had accepted, while 405 had refused. To the rest, the Government was pushing cash compensation. But the money wasn’t enough to buy even two acres of land, let alone the five acres to which they are entitled. The Ministers were shocked to learn that for every 100,000 rupees ($2,232) of cash compensation given, the Government was deducting 90,000 rupees as income tax. ‘A bribe of 20,000 rupees had to be paid for the receipt of every cheque given,’ reported the Ministers.

Dharmapur – the largest resettlement site, touted as a success story – ‘turned out to be the worst example of not doing anything’, reported the Ministers. ‘It was not possible for anyone to live there as no infrastructure had been built… not a single plot of land has been occupied by any PAF… [even though] in official papers it has been indicated that the PAFs have been settled.’

Photo: Narmada Bachao Andolan
Medha Patkar with the people of Domkhedi village that was submerged in August 2002

But this damning report – together with its central recommendation that the dam height should not be raised any further until resettlement is complete – has failed to halt the rising waters. The Narmada Control Authority has decided to raise the dam height by another 10 per cent (from 110.76 to 121.92 metres). It will defy the Supreme Court’s ruling that people should be rehabilitated fully six months beforehand, as 13,233 families have yet to be resettled at the current height. In addition, it will drown the homes of another 8,987 families. Throughout April, two displaced people, Jamsing Nargave and Bhagwatibai Jatpuria, and their leader Medha Patkar from the Narmada Bachao Andolan (NBA) – a group fighting for the rights of displaced – undertook a 20-day long hunger strike in Delhi in protest. In a bizarre twist, they were sent to hospital during their fast and then arrested for attempting suicide.

Gujarat’s right-wing Chief Minister, Narendra Modi (Worldbeaters, NI 356), started his own hunger strike to counter that of the activists. Stopping the dam’s construction, he said, would deny water to the drought-hit areas of Gujarat. It’s still doubtful how much Gujarat will gain from the SSP. According to the Government, the scheme will provide irrigation to 3,112 drought-prone villages in Gujarat and around 135 urban centres and 8,215 villages in that province will get drinking water. Yet most of the water will be going to the rich areas of south central Gujarat, while the drought-ridden areas of Saurashtra and Kutch will get a mere two per cent. Nevertheless, the country’s most powerful came out in support of Modi and his party people ransacked the NBA’s Vadodara office. Modi’s fast came to an end in less than 24 hours when the Supreme Court said work on the dam would continue for ten days till Governments submitted status reports on rehabilitation.

The Sardar Sarovar project will have 30 big dams, 135 medium dams and 3,000 small dams. The cost is high: the NBA estimates that once complete, the dam will have displaced 700,000 people. The reservoir alone will displace 51,445 families (more than 257,000 people) from 245 villages, of whom 27,934 families in 186 villages are already affected. Around 47,000 hectares of forest and 12,000 hectares fertile plains will be lost.

Many others are affected by the dam, like those displaced by irrigation canals, pumping stations, deforestation and villages on hilltops that are now islands surrounded by water. Noorzi Padvi from Denil village in Maharashtra is now living on one of these islands in the mountains, cut off for a large part of the year. ‘I wasn’t offered any resettlement. We are totally stranded and have no way to survive,’ he said.

The poor are forced to pay the price for the pipe dreams of the powerful. That’s development, desi (Indian) style.

New Internationalist, June 2006

Read more at:
www.newint.org
www.narmada.org
www.sardarsarovardam.org
www.hindu.com/2006/04/17/stories/2006041705231100.htm
www.irn.org

Wild ass in the wild west

The Little Rann of Kutch is hot, dry and salty but it has a wild ass. This barren landscape is teeming with life. The Agarias also live in this desolate mudflat to make salt.

DIONNE BUNSHA

Photo: Dionne Bunsha
A salt pan

Salt. It overpowers you when you breathe in the Little Rann of Kutch. It burns the insides of your nose. You can taste it on your tongue and lips. It makes your eyes run. All it takes is one hour in the Rann for the salt to saturate your senses.

Imagine living here. In a flat land, with cracked earth and a bare horizon broken only by the occasional salt pan or sometimes a Bet (elevated plateau or island). The only people who survive in this harsh terrain are salt pan workers known as Agarias, an OBC caste known as Chuwalia Kolis. Local legend has it that even after they are dead and cremated, the soles of an Agaria's feet remain. A lifetime of hard work in the salt pans hardens their skin so much that even fire cannot burn it.

For eight months, the Agarias camp in the Little Rann to make salt. They dig huts in the ground to protect them from the wind and the sun. There's no water, no groceries, no school, no doctor... nothing nearby. It's just them and the salt pan. They dig wells and use diesel pumps to draw out water from the saline aquifers. It's essential that water keeps flowing through the salt pan 24x7 so that the salt crystals can form properly. That's why Agarias cannot leave the salt pan unattended and go back to their villages at the edges of the Little Rann.

"We have to work like an ox everyday, pulling the rake through the water. Look at these blisters on my hand. The salt is so blinding, I can't even see properly," said Bhavan Muladia, who had set up a salt pan with his brother. "There isn't even drinking water here. We buy water from a tanker that comes every 5 days. The water costs Rs 500 per month. We get to bathe every 15 days. That's why everyone keeps falling ill here." Why continue to work in such severe conditions? "What else can we do? There's no other work. In the rains, we work in the villages on other people's farms. But after that, there's nothing. Give us a choice and we'll leave."
Photo: Dionne Bunsha
An Agaria boy at a salt pan

Who would believe that such inhospitable terrain supports so many people and very rich biodiversity? This sanctuary is home to the last surviving species of the Asiatic Wild Ass (Equus hemionus khur). It also has six threatened plant species, nine species of endangered mammals (wolf, caracal, desert cat, chinkara, blackbuck, blue bull), six threatened species of water birds (houbara bustard, lessor florican, spoon bill, peafowl, hawks, large falcons) and six vulnerable reptile species, according to a report by the Gujarat Ecological Education and Research (GEER) Foundation. Its water bodies are home to many migratory water birds and are even the nesting grounds for the lesser flamingos. Besides, there are 253 flowering plant species here.
Photo: Devjibhai Dhamecha
The Little Rann of Kutch is home to the last surviving species of the Asiatic wild ass

In the last century, the Indian Wild Ass was found all over the dry regions of north west India and west Pakistan - Jaisalmer, Bikaner, Sind and Baluchistan. Today, it is found only in the Little Rann, and a few stray towards the Great Rann of Kutch. At last count in 1998, its population was estimated at 2,940. The population has been growing since 1976. But as Wild Ass expert Nita Shah points out, long-term trends show intense fluctuations. Since the area is drought-prone, the wild ass population could be vulnerable to sudden declines. If there are no severe droughts, the species is likely to grow and disperse in the Great Rann and Rajasthan, habitat that the Wild Ass occupied in the past. The GEER report recommends that Thar Desert should be developed as an alternative site for the Indian Wild Ass.

While driving through the Rann, all you see is flat land and the sky, and often, mirages. When you see waterbodies teeming with birds, it's a surprise. The Rann's strategic location and connection to the Gulf of Kutch makes it a rich habitat for 97 species of water birds and 81 species of terrestrial birds. Nine migratory bird species also visit the Rann. The Rann also has a unique saline grassland called Banni where endemic salt tolerant grasses grow.
Photo: Devjibhai Dhamecha
Pelicans in a creek. The water bodies of the region attract at least nine species of migrant birds

“Biodiversity in these areas has remained remarkably intact because of cultural values, social controls and indigenous knowledge, maintained and enforced by community institutions such as panchayats,” says Prof. Anil K Gupta from Sristi, an organization that works to build local knowledge. “Community managed areas also harbor a large part of Gujarat's domestic and agro-biodiversity. The survival of indigenous varieties of cattle, buffalo, sheep, horse and crops is linked with the continuation of these areas.”

The Little Rann of Kutch (LRK) was once part of the Gulf of Kutch. It's a unique seasonal wetland - totally submerged in the monsoon, but transforms into a desert for the rest of the year. During the monsoon, tidal waters and water from rivers like the Banas, Rupen and Saraswati flood the mudflats. This intermingling of waters makes the Rann a vast fishing ground in the monsoon, particularly for prawns. A narrow highland near Adesar connects the Little Rann to the Great Rann of Kutch. Fossils from Jurassic times are found on some islands, so the region also has tremendous geological importance. The government plans to make it a Biosphere Reserve - where the needs of people and the environment are considered in conservation management.

Though the LRK was declared a sanctuary in 1973, it isn't one in practice because the government still hasn't sorted settlement rights and claims of the 50,000 Agarias and 8,650 fishermen here. Until settlement is complete, the forest department cannot take measures to manage or protect the sanctuary properly.
As we drive through the Rann in an old, battered jeep with Devjibhai Dhamecha, a local naturalist, he tells us, "Tourists want to see the lion in Gir, but no one is interested in wild asses. That's why Gir's protected area is 1,100 sq km, but it has 600 forest staff. That's two people for each lion. The Little Rann is spread across 5,000 sq km but we have only 35 staff posted here. And they can't do much to control growth here because settlement of the sanctuary hasn't been completed for the last 30 years."
Photo: Devjibhai Dhamecha
Though dry, the land is rich in plant life, which includes six threatened species.

Decades of unregulated development have taken their toll on the ecosystem. Cattle and sheep grazing in areas where wild animals forage has eaten into their space. Wild ass expert Nita Shah, one of the authors of the GEER report, says that changes in land use patterns in the villages surrounding the Little Rann have resulted in more wildlife-animal conflict. Unregulated vehicle traffic within the Little Rann has also disturbed bird and animal life.

The GEER Foundation report says that "(unregulated growth of) salt works have resulted in the loss of habitat, hindered the movement of wildlife, increased disturbance levels and threatened the breeding site of flamingos". One-third of the salt produced in Gujarat (which is the country's largest salt producer) is made in the LRK. The rights of salt makers cannot be ignored. The GEER report, funded by the Gujarat forest department, proposed that salt pans be restricted to seven zones on the outskirts of the sanctuary, leaving the interiors for wildlife. The government says it is planning to implement it once the settlement process is complete. However, Pradeep Khanna, Gujarat's chief conservator of forests, was reluctant to talk about any details regarding the settlement process.

The land in the Little Rann doesn't belong to any individuals. But the government has given out leases allowing people, societies and even companies to manufacture salt. While individuals have leases that extend from 10 to 20 years, companies have longer leases, one stretching up to 100 years. Only those salt workers holding leases before 12th January 1973 will be considered 'legal' while settling claims. A large majority considered 'illegal' lose their only source of livelihood. Moreover, the rights of those who have sub-leased salt pans from merchants may have no legal standing.
Photo: Dionne Bunsha
A mud hut made over a pit dug in the ground, near a salt pan

If given another option, they would gladly give up salt harvesting. Still exploited by several traders and middlemen, they have no way out of the grind. "They are living like slaves in a free country. They are totally tied to merchants for leases, loans, buying petrol for their pumps and finally selling the salt," says Dhamecha, who also comes from an Agaria family. "Agarias sell their salt for 60 paise per kg, but the market price is Rs 6 a kg, so you can imagine the extent of exploitation." Earnings from the salt pans are diminishing, as the water table falls and they have to spend more to pump water. Some have had to abandon salt pans half way through the salt producing process because there was not enough water. Salt pans have become an even more risky venture.

For the first time, Premji Muladia has to dig a second well in this salt pan. The first one ran dry. He's expecting lower production this year. "The water this year isn't as saline, so I think I will get only 750 tonnes this year. Last year, I got 950 tonnes. I won't have any money left at the end of the season," he says. "Expenses are increasing because there is less water. Even after putting in so much work, we may not get much salt."

As the government keeps delaying settlement and putting a proper co-existence plan into practice, people like Premji Muladia and their endangered ecosystem are treading a thin line for survival. They need more than just salt to sustain them.

Photo: Dionne Bunsha
The feet of an Agaria girl, weathered by the salty terrain


WEBLINKS:

World Wildlife Fund
http://www.worldwildlife.org/wildworld/profiles/terrestrial/im/im0901_full.html

The World Consevation Union
http://www.iucn.org/themes/ssc/sgs/equid/ASWAss.html

Arkive
http://www.arkive.org/species/GES/mammals/Equus_hemionus/

Frontline, April 22 - May 5, 2006 Also available here

When the dam had had enough

It was like an elephant hurtling towards them, yet many of the huts on the banks of the rivers couldn’t move out of its way when the dams swelled

DIONNE BUNSHA
in Sangli and Pune

“Everyone is zero. Everything was washed away,” Dastagir Fakir, from Sakharwadi village in Sangli, told me. That’s the common refrain in districts worst affected by the floods that followed when water was released from a series of dams along the Krishna river.

“When the water level started rising, our cattle started getting very restless and upset. We had to cut their ropes and let them go,” says Dastagir. He had spent Rs 4,000 to sow his one-acre with soyabean. It is now totally submerged. “On the first day, we were in chest-deep water. The next day, people from the village came to rescue us and took us to parts of Bhilawadi village that were not submerged. But water started rising there as well. And today, seven days later, they rescued us from the village.” Now, Dastagir and others have been crammed into small two-room school building that is functioning as a relief camp.

When 49 dams in Maharashtra swelled due to heavy rains, water was released, flooding areas more than 100 km away. In Sangli and Kolhapur, 70 villages were totally marooned. Around 2.5 lakh people in Pune, Sangli, Kolhapur and Satara had to be evacuated with the help of the army and navy, more than 1.2 lakh people in Sangli alone. However, the government says that the statistics are incomplete, the situation is far worse and information about more areas submerged keeps pouring in.

In Sangli, after the Krishna waters entered the town.

In Sangli city, more than 20,000 people are in relief camps after water released from the Koyna dam, around 120 km away, flooded their homes. Afzana Sheikh had to abandon her house barely two days after she had returned home from the hospital with her premature baby. “There was an announcement at 3 p.m. and in two hours, the water was knee-deep. By evening, it was up to our waist,” said Afzana. “First, we ran to a school nearby. But the water reached there too. Then, we went to a local marriage hall, but his also got flooded. Then, the municipal trucks brought us to this relief camp. It’s been 12 days since we left home. By now our house must be totally in water.”

After the relief camp what next? Few have faith that the government will help them get back on their feet again. “No one is thinking of what will happen after we leave here. We will have to start from scratch. They are giving us food, but we are ready to be hungry for a few days if they help us set up our homes again,” said Yuvraj Kamble, a construction worker.

“Government officials have told us that there will be a survey and we will get compensation after we go back home. But how can we start life if we have absolutely nothing, not even a stove to cook?” he asked. “Once we leave here, there will be no support. They will forget about us. Not even a single councillor has come here to meet us.” Even the chief minister’s visit to the relief camp the day before did not inspire much confidence in the administration.

In Pune city and its adjoining villages too, people had to be evacuated when water from the Pahuna, Mulshi and Mutha rivers swelled. Kausalya Belim lives on the edge of a drainage line that flows along the Mutha river's edge. “The sewage couldn’t flow into the river and so it flooded our homes,” says Kausalya. Now, the water has abated and people can go back to their broken homes, but the struggle to get relief could sink them. Officials are not surveying houses properly and compensation forms are insufficient. Moreover, each form has to be testified, so people will have to run around government offices for the ‘sarkari chaap’.

While the water receded in Pune within a few days, Sangli and Kolhapur, further south, remained submerged. The Krishna river or its tributaries flows southwards through all these districts. “Koyna, one of the largest dams, is after Pune and released water towards Sangli and Kolhapur. The amount of water released was much more, that’s why the intensity was greater,” says environmentalist Vijay Paranjpye. “It’s also a cumulative effect. As the river flows south and more overflowing tributaries keep joining the Krishna river, the amount of water in the river also increases.” There are 34 dams in the Krishna basin, and as each released water, it creates a flood further downstream.

The Maharashtra government also blames the Almatti dam authorities in Karnataka, further south on the river Krishna, for not discharging sufficient water. “This has resulted in a back- effect of water which is trapped. That’s why water levels are not falling quickly in places like Sangli, even though we are releasing large amounts of water,” said S.V. Sodal, secretary for water resources. “We had a similar swell in the Koyna dam in 1997, but the flood abated within three days because the Almatti dam had not yet been built then. This time, the Koyna dam level rose to 543 metres, three metres above the danger level. But it has fallen by only a metre in three days.”

Some of the damage could have been averted if the dam’s flood danger area had not been encorached, says Paranjpye. “Each dam authority delineates the right of way of the river. No one can infringe this. But it is blatantly violated. That’s why so many suffered, particularly in cities,” he said.

“Dams provide people with a false sense of security, which is why they encroach on the dam area. But dam’s don’t stop floods. They reduce the frequency and increase the severity of flooding,” says Paranjpye. “For many years, there was no flooding, so people were lulled into a false security and encroached on the river bed. It’s like seeing an elephant is hurtling towards you, but yet you insist on standing in its way.”

But many like Dastagir, marooned in their village, never knew they were in the way of the elephant.

Frontline, August 13 - 26, 2005 Also available here

Crocodile’s day out

Central Gujarat went under. Was it a freak downpour or did Baroda sink under the weight of its own development?

DIONNE BUNSHA
in Vadodara

Water kept rising from under Lalji Vasava’s feet when torrential rains lashed his village. Before he knew what had hit him, his entire mud hut in Ankodia village near Vadodara started crumbling. Lalji took his family and fled to the local school, where many other villagers had sought shelter. By the next morning, nothing remained of his hut.

Now homeless, Lalji rummages through the ruins, wondering how he will survive the rest of the monsoon. “I will have to take a loan from my sheth (employer). But right now, there isn’t much work either because all the fields are flooded,” he said. Lalji is still living in the local school, where the panchayat has made arrangements for their food.

Photo: AFP
Villagers and cattle take refuge on a hillock between Vadodara and Ahmedabad

When floods drowned central and south Gujarat last week, 202 died. Services like electricity and telephones shut down, houses collapsed, roads caved in and farm crops were sunk. People were stranded in trains, on roads, at home for days, not knowing when the waters would abate.

Vadodara, Anand, Kheda, Surat and Bharuch were worst affected. Some parts of Saurashtra were also flooded. The Narmada dam is overflowing by one metre. A total of 32 dams in Gujarat have overflowed this monsoon, and 39 are on high alert.

For a few days, not only people were stranded in their homes but power supply, communication and transport was cut off. Train links between Ahmedabad and Mumbai remain disabled since June 24, when the first heavy showers were reported. The Ahmedabad-Vadodara expressway had a huge crater near Vasad and was closed on July 1 and 2. The damage was the worst at Vasad, where the river ate away the embankment of the rail bridge too. Passengers were stuck in a train near Vadodara for two days, while food packets were thrown to them. The railways estimate a Rs five crore loss.

Relief crew evacuated 2.96 lakh people all over Gujarat and four to five lakh are staying in relief camps run by voluntary groups, according to state government estimates. As the water recedes, more dead bodies are likely to be recovered in interior areas. Fifty-seven towns and 6,717 villages were affected. Chief minister Narendra Modi circled the affected areas in a helicopter and ordered that food packets were dropped. The central government has allotted Rs 500 crore for relief.
Photo: Amit Dave/Reuters
Flood victims collect food packets in Mehamdabad village

Crocodiles and snakes swam in the flooded streets of Vadodara for a few days. Unusually heavy rainfall made the Pratapur dam, north of Vadodara, burst and as the waters gushed into the city, 20 km away, it also brought along reptiles for the ride. While people were stranded, unable to move out of their deluged homes, it was the crocodile’s day out.

Was the total collapse only due to the abnormally high rain? How much of it could have been avoided by proper planning?

“At places where the water to used to run into drains, the municipality has allowed buildings to come up, which blocked the flow of water. That’s why water was locked in,” says R.P. Vijay, a resident of Sama, one of the worst affected areas in Vadodara. “Our house had three feet high water. We had to live with our neighbours on the first floor for six days.”

“The Express highway and the Narmada canal construction have blocked the natural water flow into the Bhuki river. That’s why certain areas have been totally submerged. Encroachments on the river are also causing flooding,” says Pradeep Joshi, a BJP corporator from Vadodara. “The design of both these projects should be reviewed, encroachments must be removed and there should be a by-pass for the water of the Bhuki river. The Narmada authorities, the Express highway planners and the municipal corporation’s ineffectiveness are responsible for all these lives lost.”

“Yes, the expressway has caused flooding in places situated near it, and encroachments on the riverfront are also why so many people were affected,” says Gopal Shah, former town planner. “But no one could have anticipated such heavy rain. Vadodara had 50 inches of rain in eight days, while its average yearly rainfall is 30-40 inches. The city’s infrastructure was not built to deal with this kind of downpour.” Gujarat has already received 624mm of rainfall, 69% of its average.
Photo: AFP
The Dholara-Bhavanagar highway

While planning for the city and sanctioning construction or infrastructure projects, the municipal authorities don’t consider how it could affect water contours, says Rohit Prajapati, an activist of the Paryavaran Suraksha Samiti (Environment Protection Committee). “There is no concept of a water map. They build drains along canals and expressways to protect the canal or road, not the surrounding areas. Unless there is a disaster, people don’t think.”

Both the reservoirs built to prevent flooding in the city, the Pratapura dam and Ajwa lake, actually caused the deluge when they overflowed. A wall of the Pratapura dam broke and the gates of Ajwa dam were opened. The water gushed into the Vishwamitra river that flows through the city, taking crocodiles and snakes and turning the streets into fast flowing rivers. Water was locked in the city and could not find its way out. In many places, people broke roads or dividers situated on a higher level that were blocking the flow of the water.

“The water current was so strong that it broke our compound wall while entering and also the wall from where it flowed out,” says Nimish Trivedi, a resident of the newly-constructed Siddharth Bungalows in Sama. People here had to run to neighbours terraces and braved the rains for three days, while food packets were thrown to them.

In villages, farms were flooded. “Four of my buffaloes drowned. My castor crop is gone. I had sown rice, which has also been washed away. My banana trees and potato crop is ruined. Who is going to compensate for these losses?” asked Arvindbhai Ambalal Patel, a farmer from Koyali village, close to Vadodara.
Photo: Raveendran/AFP
A marooned resident of Virpur, near Vadodara

The ‘Golden Corridor’, a chemical industrial zone that runs from Vadodara to Vapi, faced the heaviest rainfall. This corridor is highly polluted, since many industries violate environmental rules. The torrential rains have eroded the little pollution control infrastructure that exists. Channels carrying effluent have broken. Crude oil from a refinery in Koyali spilled into farmlands.

“The entire lake is black because of the crude oil leak. Water has seeped into people’s fields and is also flowing downstream, contaminating those areas,” said Ramanbhai Patel, a farmer from Koyali. The Gujarat government’s disaster management plan, prepared after the Kutch earthquake, does not look at chemical disasters. While industrial losses are estimated at Rs 15,000 crore, the damage caused by effluent leakages to agricultural land, the environment and people’s health has not been accounted for.

The most telling photograph of the floods is the picture of joint commissioner of police, K.Kumaraswamy, sitting on the back of a constable while he waded through the shoulder-high water. This image is also symbolic of the plight of Gujarat’s people today. The crocodiles and snakes rule.

Frontline, July 16 - 29, 2005 Also available here

Red carpet for lions, red card for people

Some of the Gir lions needed another home. The adivasis in Kuno forest gave up theirs on promises of a better life. But were given little more than stony land

DIONNE BUNSHA
in Kuno forest, Madhya Pradesh
Akke and Kheru share a beedi with their friends and stare at the stone in front of them. Blazing heat and rugged terrain is all they have. No trees, no crop, no cattle, no food, just stony land. Nothing can be grown here. All they can do with it is hammer away, breaking rocks for construction. They get just Rs 70 for a 100 huge boulders.

Their village, Pehra, on the outskirts of the Kuno-Palpur forest located in the Vindhya hills in north western Madhya Pradesh, was moved out of the forest six years ago. Around 24 villages, 1,545 families, mainly Sahariya Adivasis, were re-located outside the jungle to create a sanctuary for 5 to 8 Asiatic lions to be translocated from the Gir forest, in Gujarat. Since they were shifted out, it’s been six years of hardship, dire poverty. The lions have yet to be brought into the forest. Meanwhile, thousands in the displaced villages are starving.

In the stark landscape of re-settled Pehra, there isn’t even a tree where Hakke and Kheru can sit in the shade. Just vast stretches of thorny, scrub bushes and the hills in the distance. “This land is useless. Every crop I tried has failed. The soil doesn’t retain any water. The government told us that we would be given fertile, irrigated land with bunding,” Hakke told us. “Forget irrigation, the land is too shallow to hold any water. The crop just dries up or gets washed away.” People who were able to grow two crops in the forest are now reduced to being footloose daily wage labourers, scouting for work everyday, not knowing where the next meal will come from. If there is a next meal.

“Now, our village is empty. There are only 20 families left in a village of more than 100 houses. Many have locked their homes and have left for Sheopur town to cut the harvest in other people’s fields,” said Kheru. “When we lived in the forest, only a few would migrate during the lean season, and it was out of choice. Here, everyone has to keep travelling, searching for work. We didn’t even know how to break stones.” Reminiscing about his old village, he continued, “We could grow two crops without irrigation. At this time, farmers would be selling their harvest. We would swim in the river. Instead, here we are, sweating in the sun, breaking rocks.”

Photo: Ashima Narain
Kheru and his friends breaking rocks after they were displaced from their homes in the forest to make way for a pride of Asiatic Lions that have not been translocated years after the sanctuary was created for them

Even when they lived inside the forest, the Adivasis were poor, but life is worse after re-location. “The forest gave us all we needed - milk, ghee, fruits, vegetables, animals, herbs, berries. We got money from selling, tendu leaves, gum etc,” says Munna, from Jakhoda village, who has been suffering with TB for two years. “Here, people don’t even get to eat rotis on some days, so they fall ill. We didn’t need a doctor.” People’s diet reduced drastically. In many of the re-located villages, children are malnourished. One who we came across in Paira died days after we left.

People were moved out with the promise of better facilities, but even water is scarce. “In the forest, we had the river. Here there’s just one hand pump in the village for so many families. There’s no water for baths,” said Kheru. “Cattle can’t survive here because there’s no grazing ground. We had to abandon all our cattle in the forest. Now, if we want to plough the field, we have to hire a tractor and pay an additional Rs 1,800.” With every attempt to sow the land, debts keep accumulating. People borrow to sow the fields, but there is no crop.

After several years of losses, the people of Pipalbawdi village decided to return to the forest for the monsoon crop in 2004. The forest department let them. They knew that the land they were given in the re-located village was barren. “We stayed there for three years, but there was no crop, no work. Here, there is as much fertile land as your heart desires. We don’t need to go anywhere for work,” said Ramdayal. He was part of a large group that gathered round, weary, but eager to speak. “So many years without any crop drained us completely. After many crop failures, people have huge loans to pay off - up to Rs 30,000-40,000, at 60% interest.”

Sabu’s family harvested a mustard crop this year, but all of it went to the bania (trader), paying back a loan. At the end, they were left with nothing. “At least now, we are making up years of losses,” she said. The nearest doctor or bus stand is 9 km away in Agraa village. There’s no transport, people have to walk there. The school inside the forest doesn’t have a teacher. Yet, the people of Pipalbawdi feel they are better off inside. Says a lot about their “Rehabilitation” and the “better facilities” they were promised outside. Besides Pipalbawdi, there are two other villages inside the forest. Still, they are willing to go back to the re-settlement village if they are given suitable land on which they can grow a crop.

A few days after we visited Pipalbawdi, there were reports that forest officials punished and harassed villagers, and pulled them up for not moving back to their re-location site and speaking to journalists. Around 40 men and a few women were reportedly forced into forest department vehicles and taken to their outpost at Pohri, 50 km away, according to Samrakshan, an NGO working in the area. However, Chief Forest Officer, J.S. Chauhan said, “They were asked to come out for their own good. We let them cultivate the rabi (winter) crop inside and now they have nothing to do. If they come out of the forest, we can give them some daily wage work.” He denied that the eviction was prompted by our visit.

Kuno was selected for shifting a pride of Asiatic lions from Gir in Gujarat. Scientists from the WII felt that translocation of some of the expanding population of Gir lions was necessary to preserve the last surviving lions of the species. If an epidemic were to hit the lions in Gir, an entire species could be wiped off the face of the planet. So, a satellite population in Kuno is necessary. That meant declaring 345 sq km of the forest as a sanctuary and re-locating 24 villages outside the forest. Although the villages have been re-located, the Gujarat government refuses to shift the lions, it wants them to remain in Gujarat alone.

The Kuno rehabilitation package offered evicted Adivasis a deal that was supposed to improve the quality of their lives. They would have access to electricity, transport, schools, dispensaries, irrigated land, grazing grounds, firewood plantations and money for house construction. It was “voluntary”, villagers agreed to move. The rehabilitation was considered “successful” by many wildlife conservationists. J.S. Chauhan, then co-ordinating the project, was given the Sanctuary Wildlife Award 2002 for Earth Heroes. Despite a comparatively good rehabilitation package (compared to displaced people in other parts of the country), re-located people are worse off in their new relocation sites.
Photo: Ashima Narain
Adivasis from Jahkoda village in Sheopur district find it difficult to survive after being displaced

There are a few who feel they’ve got a good deal. “We have more facilities- electricity, a doctor close at hand, transport. Yes, there are many things promised but not given like fodder and firewood plantations, some irrigation wells haven’t been dug, electricity for pumps. But there are bound to be problems, nothing is perfect,” said Mahesh Mirda, sarpanch of Palpur village. His brother, Suresh, disagreed. “They brought us in the middle of nowhere, where there was one handpump and nothing else and left us to die. What’s the point of running a school if there is one teacher for 250 children? They fooled us and got us out of the forest.”

Village leaders were shown various properties and asked to approve their re-location sites. Then, land was distributed amongst people on a lottery basis. “The powerful people took the land closer to the river, and we were left with stone,” said Ramkali, from Paira. Moreover, when the forest officials showed people the land, they were promised it would be cleared of all bush and made suitable for cultivation. The clearing was done but there was no land or watershed development.
Photo: Ashima Narain
Even water is scarce in the 'rehabilitated' villages

“The entire responsibility of rehabilitation cannot be placed on the forest dept. alone. We don’t have the technical expertise, and need the help of other departments like irrigation, education or health. We have tried to respond to all complaints,” says Chauhan. “For irrigation, we have asked for more funds. It’s not easy to irrigate 3,000 hectares. With the help of other departments, it will take 5 to 6 years. If we have to do it on our own, it could take 15 to 20 years.” Chauhan feels that rehabilitation projects should be undertaken with a different approach. “Yes, the forest dept. should have been more visionary, but why did people agree?”

So, how “voluntary” was the re-settlement? Were people really given a choice between staying in the forest or moving out? Or was it more like a fait accompli? “They wanted us out of the forest so they promised us Rs 1,00,000, but we got only Rs. 38,000 in cash. The government spent the rest of the money to build facilities and clear the land,” said Suresh. “We agreed to come out because they promised us so much money, and assured us that we would get the same kind of land. People have never seen that kind of money, we got greedy and realised later that we had been fooled,” said Hakke.

Now, Kuno jungle is supposedly free from human degradation. Forest officials claim the prey (like deer, chital, wild boar) for lions has increased. The scene is set for the arrival of the Asiatic lion from Gujarat.

At what cost? Was there another, less destructive way possible? “In India, finding a large enough forest for carnivores is difficult because our population density is so high and our forests are degraded and fragemented. After looking at all other alternatives, Kuno was found more suitable. When we spoke to people, they were willing to move,” said Ravi Chellam, lion expert who was part of the WII team that recommended translocation to Kuno. “They can’t remain inside the forest with the lion. That might lead to conflict.”

Yet, with no other alternative, many Adivasis like those in Pipalbawdi, would prefer to break the law rather than break rocks.

Frontline, May 21 - June 3, 2005 Also available here

A kingdom too small

Lions in Gir look for new territories as the sanctuary is not large enough for their population

DIONNE BUNSHA
in Sasan, Gir forest, Gujarat
Photographs: Ashima Narain


A lion prowling the beach? Yes, small groups of the last surviving Asiatic Lions in the world have moved out of the Gir Sanctuary in Saurashtra, Gujarat, towards the coastal forests of Diu. They haven't disturbed any sunbathers yet. Nor have they attacked people in the coastal villages.


The Gir protected area is simply too small for the only 327 Asiatic Lions on the planet, so the younger ones have moved out in search of prey - as far as Diu, around 80 km away.

"It may seem unusual to find a lion on the coast, but this isn't the first time that they have reached the shore," says Bharat Pathak, Conservator of Forest (Wildlife), Junagadh. Lions were spotted in the coastal areas in the early 1900s as well, according to the Junagadh Gazetteer. Now, as the lion population is larger and open grasslands are shrinking, they are dispersing to reclaim the 2,560 sq. km. they once occupied in 1956. The Gir protected area is only 1,421 sq km of dry, deciduous forest, a little more than half the original size of the forest. There are territorial fights between lions, and only the strong retain their territories. The sub-adults have to move out.

There are now three or four lion populations outside the protected area. A pride of 13 lions live in the Girnar hills, 20 roam the coastal areas, 16 are in the Hipavadli-Savarkundla region and 7 in other places. The number of lions has exceeded the sanctuary's estimated carrying capacity, says Dr Ravi Chellam, an expert on the Asiatic lions in Gir. Chellam’s survey, while with the Wildlife Institute of India (WII), recommended that they be shifted to Kuno, a forest in northern Madhya Pradesh, more than 1,000 km away.

“Just because their population has increased in the last two decades does not mean that the long-term future of wild Asiatic lions is secure,” says Dr Chellam’s report for the WII. “If restricted to a single site which is relatively small in size, the lions face many extinction threats - genetic and environmental. Catastrophes like an epidemic could result in the extinction of an endangered species.” The WII report points out how a canine distemper epidemic in the early 1990s at the Serengeti National Park in Tanzania affected 75% of the lions and killed 30%, even though there was a large lion population spread over a vast area. “If a similar epidemic were to affect the lions in Gir, it would be very difficult to save them from extinction, given the much smaller area and relatively smaller lion population,” says the report.

The WII suggested preparing 400 sq km of the 3,700 sq. km forest in Kuno for the Asiatic lions over a 5-8 year period. Around 7,400 people in 19 villages will have to be moved out to make way for the 8-odd adult lions and their young, who will be brought here once the prey base is adequate. Several villages have been moved out of the forest. But, the Gujarat government refuses to move the lions outside the state. It wants the lions to remain uniquely 'Gujarati'.

"Rather than move it further away from Gir, we are planning to shift some lions to Barda, a sanctuary near Porbandar," says Pathak. Gujarat’s Conservator of Forest (Wildlife), Pradeep Khanna, feels that the alternative location of the lion is not justified. “We are facilitating the expansion of the lion’s home zone. There is no need to re-locate them. Re-introduction of a carnivore in a new environment is not so easy. An earlier effort has failed. Moreover, there are tigers in the Kuno forest. When natural dispersal of lions is taking place around Gir, why interfere with nature?”

"There's already too much in-breeding. That's why 70% of cubs don't survive," says P.P. Rawal, chief forest conservator, Gir. "You need at least 250 pairs for the survival of any species. Right now, we have only 92 males and 100 females in their reproductive years. What sense does it make to separate them further? We must first ensure they propagate and then let them disperse."

Several wildlife experts disagree with the Gujarat government’s adamant stand. “The Gujarat government has successfully increased the number of Asiatic Lions. But we need to manage that success and think long term. It’s better to avoid risk. How would it hurt if just 5-8 adults are removed from the population?” asks Dr Chellam. “Their positions are misinformed. They say it is dangerous for the lions to be in tiger territory. But just eight tigers in Kuno pose no grave threat. The lions came to India and settled in the same north-central forests where tigers lived. They have co-existed in the past, maintaining an uneasy truce. Lions live in the dry, grasslands, whereas the tigers move in the thick, dense forest.”

While the disappearance of India's tiger population raises a national outcry, the gentle Asiatic Lion's fragile existence doesn't cause the same alarm. India has 3,000-odd tigers in 27 reserves. But there are only 327 Asiatic lions (according to the last lion census in 2000) confined in only one small sanctuary, Gir.

The Asiatic lion (Panthera leo persica) is different from the African lion in its genetic make-up, skeletal structure and appearance. Asiatic lions have a loose skin fold on the belly and their mane is less dense.

The Asiatic lion once inhabited Asia Minor and Arabia through Persia to India. In the Indian sub-continent, its range extended over northern India as far as east up to Bihar and Orissa, with the Narmada river marking the southern limit. Before the close of the last century, the Asiatic lion had become extinct from its range except Gir. The last lion surviving in the wild outside Saurashtra was reported in 1884. “The last few lions remain in Gir because it a compact, unfragmented ecosystem. And, since the time of the Nawab of Junagadh, there have been continuous conservation efforts here. Moreover, the local people respect nature and our staff work hard to preserve the forest,” says Pathak.

One of the first to rescue the lions from extinction was surprisingly once a Shikhar (hunter) - the Nawab of Junagadh (a princely state in Saurashtra, where Gir is located). At the turn of the 20th century, he was shocked to find that only 12 lions remained in the grassland. He declared a ban on lion hunting and made sure the lions were protected. After his death, the British administration tried to control hunting in the forest.

The first lion census was in 1936, which estimated the lion population at 287 lions. The number dropped to 177 in 1968, because the lion's grassland habitat was shrinking. In 1965, the government started the lion conservation programme and declared the area a sanctuary. Since then, the lion population has been growing steadily. Counting for the next census will be in April 2005.

Within the small confines of the Gir sanctuary is not pristine, there are many disturbances to nature. Five state highways and a railroad pass through the forest. The forest has 2.5 lakh tourists every year. More tourists enter the forest to visit its three big temples (in all there are 23 religious shrines in the forest) than those that go on wildlife safaris. There is widespread limestone mining in villages just outside the sanctuary. One of four cement factories is as close as 15 km away from the protected area.

This destroys the natural habitat and drains forest resources, including water, a precious resource in the dry summers. Water holes within the sanctuary are dry up, pushing lions to go out in search of both water and prey. Watering holes are also places where it's easier to find prey like deer and blue bull. Recently, lions have fallen into wells in villages on the outskirts of the forest.
Rather than tackle these problems, the government is intent on getting rid of the Maldharis, local herdsmen who have co-existed with the lions inside the forest. The Maldharis live in small settlements, each called a 'Ness'. There were 129 Nesses in the forest. Often, lions prey on their cattle, but the Maldharis don't try to aggressively defend their livestock. They accept it as part of nature's cycle. The government offers them Rs 5,000 compensation, but the process of claiming it is long and bureaucratic.

In 1972, the government tried to relocate some Nesses outside the sanctuary. It shifted 580 of the 845 Maldhari families living inside the forest. Though they were given land, the Maldharis didn't do well as farmers. Many sold off their land. A few didn't leave, or returned to their old nesses. Today, there are 54 Nesses (400 families) inside the sanctuary.

Most Maldharis prefer to settle in the forest, even if it means that they live in small, secluded huts, with minimal facilities like electricity or water supply. And, transport facilities are few and access to markets, schools and hospitals is difficult.

Dadhiya ness, which had 50 people, was shifted in the ‘70s. Now only 12 families remain. "We didn't go to the new land, only half our family moved out. The land they gave as compensation was stony, you can't farm on that land," says Jaggo Ruda Jatwa. "We have 25 cattle, so we stay here. There's nothing for us outside the sanctuary. What will we feed the cattle? We don't know farming."

Moving the Maldharis outside the forest will improve their quality of life and preserve the forest, says Pathak. “If they live in the forest, it degrades the habitat. Their cattle graze in direct competition with prey like deer.” But experts question the forest department’s priorities. “Relocating the Maldharis is not going to solve the problem. It is more important to translocate the lions,” says Dr Chellam. “For the survival of the lions, the Maldharis are not an issue. Lions can co-exist with humans. You need to be careful while re-locating people. Wildlife conservation need not be purist.”

Both the Maldharis and the trackers, who live with animals everyday, have detailed knowledge of the forest. "Without the Maldharis, the lions cannot survive," says a tracker with long and intimate knowledge of the forest. “The Maldharis and their livestock are essential to the forest ecosystem. Yes, the cattle eat grass, but without their droppings, how will the grass grow? They are not competing for grazing space with other lion prey like deer, who mainly eat leaves." However, Dr Chellam feels the lions can survive without Maldharis. “Over the years the number of wild prey animals (essentially chital deer) increased dramatically after some Maldhari villages were relocated and the national park was created. Gradually the lions have changed their diets from being mainly livestock feeders to wild prey feeders.”

"After the Maldharis were moved out, the lions have also moved beyond the outskirts of the forest because there are more human settlements with cattle there,” says the tracker. “Even though the deer population has increased dramatically, the lions prefer cattle. The last census found less prevalence of lions in the core national park area than in the sanctuary surrounding it." But, Dr Chellam says that the lion are moving out of the sanctuary because of a lack of space rather than food.

As we keep debating what’s best for them, the kings of the jungle seem to be moving out to regain their lost territories. If we can’t make place for them, they seem to be carving out their own spaces, even at the beach. But that alone may not save the species. Some have to be moved much further than the beach.

(This is the first in a two-part series on the existence of the last surviving Asiatic Lions. The next part will look at the displacement of Adivasis in the Kuno forest, Madhya Pradesh to prepare the forest for the translocation of the Asiatic Lions)

Frontline, May 07 - 20, 2005 Also available here